The guideChapter 5

The sources AI engines read

Published Last reviewed

In short

  • Start with the sources in answers to your buyers' questions, then check what each source actually supports.
  • Correct information you control and respect the editorial rules of sources you don't control.
  • Treat new content and outside coverage as experiments, with no promised citation outcome.

Start with a question and its sources

An AI answer about a product deserves the same scrutiny as a buying recommendation from a person. Open its supporting links. Read them.

Google says its AI search features may run related searches across subtopics and data sources. The resulting links can vary between features. 1

Our recommendation is to classify the sources you observe into the families below. This is a working inventory, without a universal ranking of importance.

Keep the exact question beside the answer. A question about cancellation terms needs different evidence from a question about daily use.

For a fictional booking service, cancellation terms belong on its own website. A customer's account of a refund offers a different perspective.

Read both against the same question. Check whether the customer's experience concerned an older policy before treating the accounts as contradictory.

Record who published each source and when its relevant facts were checked. Keep source ownership separate from source format. A brand can publish a video or sponsor an editorial list.

Brand websites establish what a business offers

Start with information your team can verify directly. Publish the conditions of an offer alongside its price. Explain limitations where a buyer would encounter them.

For software, that might mean documenting which subscription includes an integration. For a store, it could mean explaining where a warranty applies.

Our recommendation is to give each important fact a clear home. A support answer should link to the current policy when that policy changes.

Google requires pages to be indexed and eligible for a search snippet before they can appear as supporting links in its AI features. Eligibility doesn't guarantee inclusion. 1

Make essential information available as text. Google also says structured data should match the visible page. It requires neither special AI files nor special schema for these features. 1

We use schema for accurate descriptions and applicable search features. We don't sell schema, FAQ formatting or llms.txt as citation levers.

The same judgment applies to artificial chunking or statistics added solely to attract citations. Improve the explanation because someone needs it.

Before commissioning another article, ask a colleague to find the answer using only your public website. Any unresolved ambiguity becomes an editing task.

Reviews and directories need accurate participation

Treat a directory profile as a factual record. Check its business category and the destination of its website link. Remove claims your team cannot substantiate.

For customer reviews, invite an honest account of the experience. Our recommendation is to use a consistent request process that welcomes criticism.

Don't write the review for the customer. Don't have staff pose as customers. A review should describe something the reviewer actually experienced.

Google Maps prohibits fabricated experiences and incentivized reviews. Its rules also prohibit incentives for revising or removing negative reviews. 2

That is a Google Maps policy. Read the rules of each review platform before running a request campaign.

Suppose a customer says an appointment was cancelled without notice. Investigate the booking and explain the resolution without publishing their private information.

If the complaint reveals an unclear cancellation process, fix that process and its public explanation. Don't turn the reply into a sales pitch.

When assessing reviews as evidence, record the relevant product version or location. Keep an isolated report distinct from a pattern supported by additional accounts.

Our priority would be accurate profiles and responsible responses. We wouldn't buy a review package to manufacture apparent customer support.

Journalism and editorial lists require independence

A useful press pitch gives an editor something they can check. Offer an original finding with its method, or access to someone with relevant experience.

If a journalist gets a product detail wrong, send the precise correction and its supporting document. Leave their evaluation to them.

For an editorial comparison, ask how products were selected. Read the testing criteria before deciding whether the list is relevant to your buyers.

Our recommendation is to keep sponsorship visible to readers. Decline paid inclusion presented as an independent recommendation.

Google asks publishers to mark paid links with rel="sponsored". It also accepts nofollow for that purpose. 3

A link attribute describes the relationship to a search engine. Our editorial standard also requires a clear sponsorship label for the reader.

Google's policy on site reputation abuse addresses third-party content hosted mainly to benefit from an established site's ranking signals. Third-party content alone doesn't establish abuse. 4

For any proposed placement, evaluate its audience and editorial purpose. A seller's promise to borrow a famous domain's authority is a reason to decline.

Commission useful research if there is a real question to answer. Treat any subsequent AI citation as an observation to measure.

Communities add accounts of actual use

In its February 22, 2024 announcement, Reddit described structured Data API access for Google. The announcement covers displaying content and supporting model training. 5

That establishes an access arrangement. It doesn't tell a brand which comment will appear in an answer.

Our recommendation is to read discussions for specific questions your documentation leaves unresolved. A repeated setup problem is a reason to improve the setup guide.

Where a community permits brand participation, identify your affiliation and address the question directly. A useful reply can acknowledge a product limitation.

Imagine someone asking whether a device works without an internet connection. Explain which functions require connectivity, with a link only if the community allows it.

Reddit prohibits repeated or unsolicited mass engagement. Its spam guidance also directs contributors to community rules and moderators when unsure. 6

Avoid turning a conversation into a distribution target. Don't copy the same promotional reply across discussions.

When reviewing a cited thread, read the surrounding comments. Record disagreements and distinguish a user's experience from a claim you have independently checked.

Video should demonstrate something worth seeing

Use video when seeing the task helps someone understand it. A product demonstration can show a limitation that a promotional sentence leaves unclear.

Our recommendation is to show the relevant version and explain the conditions of the demonstration. Keep the accompanying written explanation current.

Google documents how videos can be discovered and indexed for search. Its guidance includes accessible video elements and descriptive metadata. 7

Those are search requirements and recommendations. We wouldn't interpret them as proof that publishing a video increases AI recommendations.

For a fictional kitchen appliance, demonstrate the cleaning procedure with the parts actually supplied. Say when an optional accessory is being used.

Add accurate captions and a useful written account of the demonstration. Review automatic transcription before treating it as product documentation.

If an AI answer links to a video, inspect the linked passage or timestamp. Check whether the demonstration supports the claim made about your product.

A source link alone doesn't establish that the answer understood the video correctly.

Encyclopedias have their own inclusion standards

Treat an encyclopedia entry as an independently maintained reference. Our recommendation is to correct demonstrable errors through its editorial process.

English Wikipedia's company notability guideline requires significant coverage in multiple reliable, independent secondary sources. A collection of routine announcements doesn't establish that standard. 8

Its conflict-of-interest guidance strongly discourages editing affected articles directly. It provides a process for proposing changes on discussion pages. Paid contributors must disclose relevant affiliations. 9

For a factual correction, explain your relationship to the organization and supply an appropriate source. Allow uninvolved editors to assess the request.

Don't commission a covert promotional entry. Don't treat an encyclopedia page as a deliverable that every business should obtain.

If the subject lacks sufficient independent coverage, leave it there. Publish accurate company information on your own website instead.

Apply each encyclopedia's actual rules. The existence of a page would still leave its effect on AI answers to be measured.

Choose the next action from the evidence

Google defines scaled content abuse as producing many pages mainly to manipulate rankings while providing little value. The policy applies regardless of how those pages are created. 4

We therefore reject mass-produced comparison pages that merely swap product names. We also reject undisclosed paid rankings and fake reviews.

For legitimate work, start with a source record for a real buying question. Write down the source URL and the statement it supports.

Assign a concrete next action. An outdated price needs a correction. An unanswered compatibility question needs documentation. A valid complaint needs investigation.

Record the change date, then revisit the same questions under comparable conditions. Keep brand mentions separate from links to sources.

Our article on being cited without being recommended develops that distinction.

Choose work that helps the buyer even if no AI citation follows. That gives the project a defensible purpose from the start.

Sources

  1. Google Search Central, AI features and your websiteAccessed Back to the text, first mention of source 1
  2. Google Maps, Prohibited and restricted contentAccessed Back to the text, first mention of source 2
  3. Google Search Central, Qualify your outbound links to GoogleAccessed Back to the text, first mention of source 3
  4. Google Search Central, Spam policies for Google web searchAccessed Back to the text, first mention of source 4
  5. Reddit, Expanding our Partnership with Google, February 22, 2024Accessed Back to the text, first mention of source 5
  6. Reddit Help, SpamAccessed Back to the text, first mention of source 6
  7. Google Search Central, Video SEO best practicesAccessed Back to the text, first mention of source 7
  8. English Wikipedia, Notability for organizations and companiesAccessed Back to the text, first mention of source 8
  9. English Wikipedia, Conflict of interestAccessed Back to the text, first mention of source 9